Dancing with Systems
Dancing with Systems (co-hosted by Dr Sally Uren and Prof. Dr Wayne Visser) aims to help change agents from across the spectrum - in business, government, academia, and civil society - better understand the complex set of dynamics at play in the extraordinary systems transitions currently underway.
This debut season will explore how six key systems - energy, food, finance, technology, nature and health - are evolving, examine where the key sticking points to transformation lie, and ask what actions will help unlock meaningful systems change.
Dancing with Systems
S1.E6: The Symbiocene: Business, Boards, and the Nature Transition
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Reconnecting economics with the foundational system of life.
Nature is the foundational baseline of our global economy, yet mainstream financial systems have long priced its preservation at effectively zero. With wildlife populations declining by 73% since 1970, nature loss poses a severe, systemic threat to economic stability. In this Season 1 finale, Wayne and Sally explore how businesses can shift from extracting natural capital to embedding nature at the highest levels of governance, strategy, and culture.
Guests
Eva Zabey — CEO, Business for Nature
Charmian Love — Chief International Advocacy Officer, Natura &Co; Legal Representative for Mother Nature and Future Generations on the Board of House of Hackney
What We Cover
- Grounding the economic reliance on nature: $58 trillion of global GDP relies on healthy ecosystems
- The $2.6 trillion imbalance: How harmful government subsidies dwarf conservation spending and why fiscal reform is crucial
- Moving beyond reporting checklists: Leveraging frameworks like TNFD and Integrated Profit & Loss (IP&L) for strategic decision-making
- Giving nature a voice at the top: Pioneering nature governance, including Mother Nature’s seat on corporate boards
- Transitioning from the Anthropocene to the Symbiocene through cultural shifts, personal appreciation, and biophilia
- Season 1 reflections: How policy, market signals, technology, and social movements intersect to trigger positive tipping points
Key Quotes
"We work in an economic system where we value nature when it's dead—when timber is cut, when fish are caught, when soil is degraded. We need to shift to valuing nature that is the living, breathing, regenerating system." — Eva Zabey
"We must be guided by the science, and we will be moved by the poetry." — Charmian Love (quoting Nigel Topping)
References
- Business for Nature: businessfornature.org
- Natura &Co: naturaandco.com
- Taskforce on Nature-related Financial Disclosures (TNFD): tnfd.global
- Kunming-Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework: www.cbd.int/gbf
- Dasgupta Review on the Economics of Biodiversity: www.gov.uk/government/publications/final-report-the-economics-of-biodiversity-the-dasgupta-review
This Episode's Dance
The Rumba & African Dance — The Rumba, often performed barefoot as the "dance of love," symbolizes the need for grounded, deeply felt connection and care for nature. Paired with traditional African dance, it brings the high-energy rhythm, Earth-stamping connection, and cyclical vitality required to drive system-wide regeneration
Well, welcome to the final episode of this season of Dancing with Systems, and it's one I've really been looking forward to. It's the nature episode. And well, would we consider nature a sector? In fact, uh it underlies the whole economy. It is foundational. And yet what we know is that the way that the economic system is currently set up, it's still cheaper to destroy an ecosystem than actually to value it. The price of nature, if we don't price it correctly, is effectively zero. We're all probably familiar with some of those uh rather um breathtaking statistics uh such as uh those of the Living Planet Index, where we've lost 73% of wildlife population since 1970. Always have to take a deep breath. You know, it's taken us 3.8 billion years to build up that life. And w where are we? 60 years in, 70 years in, and uh and so much of it lost. So this is not just a a sort of environmental statistic. To me, that is absolutely systemic risk because it is the foundation of our economy. Um but we have also seen uh responses. We've seen uh uh the breakthrough of the Kunming Montreal uh uh biodiversity framework in 2022. Uh we've we've had a uh a business and biodiversity assessment come out, we've got the task force on nature-related financial disclosures, so there is a lot happening. But uh Sally, maybe you could give us a few more facts and figures just to ground us.
SPEAKER_02When you start to look at nature, there are lots of very big numbers. The first very big number, which is in fact half of the world's global economy, $58 trillion of global GDP comes from sectors dependent on nature. So that is pharmaceuticals, food, a whole set of companies dependent on nature when you track down their supply chains to the source. Yet less than only 1% of companies disclose biodiversity impact. So we've got a massive mismatch between reliance, economic reliance on nature and disclosure. Then we have another big number, but it is slightly smaller: 2.6 trillion in annual government subsidies actually harm nature. This will be legislation that hasn't caught up with our understanding of ecosystem losses, and that's 10 times more money than actually goes in to protect nature. So again, another mismatch, an imbalance. Talking now about value to gain, if we act now on biodiversity, we could unlock 10 trillion in business opportunity, a staggering 395 million jobs by 2030. But if we delay, then we double the cost. So a set of numbers that say we don't really quite yet understand the reliance on our economy in terms of its reliance on nature. We're not disclosing the impacts. We've got a set of policies and regulation that keep harming nature. Yet if we act now, we could unlock huge commercial opportunities and every government's dream jobs.
SPEAKER_00Well, I think that sets the context and and and really underscores why we're ending with this episode because it is so foundational uh to everything. Uh, what are you hoping to hear about from our guests?
SPEAKER_02Yes, um, two things. Having been in this field a while, I'm very aware of all these nature-based risk disclosure frameworks. Um, and I'm just curious to know to what degree are these frameworks getting incorporated into strategic decision making? And then I'm really curious to know about the governance. Um, one of the reasons why we have this mismatch between our reliance on nature and the way it shows up in company governance, is nature isn't actually at the table. So could nature be at the boardroom table? Would that shift how we govern for nature? What about you?
SPEAKER_00Well, what I see, and it happened with climate as well, is in the nature space we're moving very quickly and strongly into measurement uh and and maybe even disclosure. And my question is, uh does that move the needle? Just because we measure it, does it mean that we're uh actually starting to turn the corner on those impacts? Uh so I'd be interested to hear about that. Uh and then almost uh conversely uh to the whole measurement story, uh what's the importance of a personal, even an emotional connection to nature? How does that factor into whether we get the systems change that we want? It makes me think of that wonderful Japanese concept, uh Shinrin Yoku, which is forest bathing uh or or what we might call uh you know nature therapy. Uh it's well proved in in science that uh you know nature really does benefit uh us. So you know let's factor that in. Let's not pretend this is only uh a sort of a rational uh way to make uh systems change. Uh well, let's get to our first guest. Who is that, Sally?
SPEAKER_02Our first guest today is the wonderful Eva Zabi, who is CEO of Business for Nature, which is a global coalition that harnesses business leadership and momentum to push for ambitious business and policy action towards a, and you've got to love this, a nature-positive economy. That would be a wonderful thing to deliver. Prior to joining Business for Nature in 2019, and it's when I met Eva, she was at the World Business Council for Sustainable Development, leading projects on natural social and human capital measurement and valuation. She was listed in the Independent Climate 100 change makers and also named Nature Champion of the Year in the 2024 Women in Green Business Awards. She is really well placed to give us the overview of where we are in the nature transition.
SPEAKER_00Perfect. Let's hear from her now. Welcome, Eva, to our podcast, uh, Dancing with Systems, and we're delighted to have you. We are dealing with the most fundamental of systems, which is nature, and of course, that's at the heart of your work, and we're really looking forward to hearing your insights. I'll start with what for most should be an obvious question, but I'd like your answer on which is why do we need to change uh our relationship to nature, uh, particularly our economic relationship, and and where have we got to in the transition of that transformation that we need?
SPEAKER_03Thanks so much, and it's great to be here with you. Uh to begin with, absolutely all of us, all businesses, all economies rely on nature. We need the freshwater, the land, the oceans, the biodiversity, soil health, pollination, the list go on. Um, but we're all part of an economic and financial system that treats the natural world as if it was a limitless source of raw materials. In fact, market rules make it cheaper to degrade an ecosystem than to protect it, and that's because we haven't really accounted for the true value of nature. It's not recognized, it's not included in mainstream decision making and disclosure. And that means that we've lost over 70% of all wildlife populations since 1970. That's one stat. But why does that matter? Because all of this biodiversity and a rich ecosystem services that work and natural worlds that work is the foundation for a healthy economy and healthy societies. Um, I think what we're seeing in the transition is that for generations, many people have seen protecting nature as strictly an eco-centric moral duty. And today, finally, we're seeing in this transition a recognition of the fact that it's a matter of human and economic security. Nature losses is a systemic risk to global market stability, it's a systemic risk to our financial structures and our long-term well-being. Of course, many others, like indigenous peoples and other uh organ, you know, local communities, may have a much more direct and deeper understanding of the value of nature, but within the existing global financial and economic systems, that's not being recognized.
SPEAKER_02Thank you for that overview, Eva. Um, you know, really compelling us to you know why we need to reposition our relationship with nature. And you mentioned that you know we have started to make some progress. I would love to know from your perspective, what are the the levers that have been pulled to enable the progress that we've seen, particularly, I'd say, over the last five years, where we have sort of shifted from a conversation that you know we need nature for key supply chains, that sort of ecocentric view, to where we are today, which is we're seeing nature as possibly the biggest systemic risk facing the global economy. What has enabled that sort of repositioning and that progress that we've seen so far?
SPEAKER_03I think there are probably three uh levers that come to mind. Thanks, Sally, when you ask that question. One is um within the businesses themselves. So companies are finally recognizing, thanks to many global frameworks out there that are that are supporting the companies with this, but understanding the nature-related risks within their operations and their value chains. If you're a hydropower company and your reservoirs have loads of sedimentation because you've cut the trees upstream of the forest, that's not good for your business. If you're an agri company, you know, any agri company that relies on natural pollination or pest control, that's also not going to be good if you're losing those services. So I think there's quite a self-interested understanding. It may not be called nature, it may not be under the sustainability agenda, but it is around supply chain resilience. Um, and companies are also, I think, feeling internally their employee attraction, retention, they are being asked more questions from investors about the long-term resilience of their business models, and um you know, we can't hide away from the fact that we are losing nature at an unprecedented rate, and that needs to be internalized within business strategies. So I think that's one of the shifts that we're seeing is that companies understanding that nature needs to be embedded in their corporate strategy alongside freshwater, climate, you know, and all these other interrelated um uh topics for the benefit of the company's financial performance and success. The second lever I think we really need to be, we're seeing shifts in and we need to be doubling down on is of course policy action and regulatory shifts, in particular around reforming incentives, which I think is the greatest opportunity. Government-led fiscal and financial incentives is the elephant in the room. We know about um the fact that you know $2.6 trillion each year unintentionally flow to subsidies that are harmful for the environment. Um that we if it you know, all these other discussions about different financial flows and mechanisms are dwarfed in comparison. It's really a trillion-dollar pivot that we need so that we can reward this long-term resilience and regeneration. Um, so that's why also at Business for Nature we're really focusing on this and trying to get businesses to be part of that conversation because governments will not have the courage and comfort to change those incentive structures without the you know, the confidence that businesses will be ready for that transition. Um, and these subsidies have been put in place with real socioeconomic reasons uh for farmers, for you know, people's livelihoods all depend on it. So it's not about turning off the tap overnight, it's about what it's the transition to incentivize better, you know, better actions. Um, and there are some good examples on that. And then the the third, I would finally say, in terms of the levers that we need to pull, is sharpening our arguments in a volatile world, especially right now. We've got to move past what can be seen as lofty, abstract, you know, really rhetoric, feel-good, bit fuzzy concepts and move to much more concrete evidence of really how nature degradation directly harms local systems, businesses, you know, investments right now. And so maybe it's best, you know, nowadays not to start with the S-word, sustainability, or the B words, biodiversity, it doesn't matter. You'll lose people from the get-go if you start with that. But if you go straight with a tangible example of how it speaks to them and why they depend on nature, then you can understand and build back up bottom up. So um uh that that's where I feel like the direction that we need to go in. Um, and that's quite exciting, in fact, to think about how those pieces can come together.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and uh some of what we've had recently, of course, should be helpful uh on on the policy front, the uh the uh Kunming Montreal Agreement. Uh so we've got our global policy, we've we've had the DAS Gupta Review, which is kind of like the Stern Review on the economics of biodiversity and ecosystems, um, and and we've got the task force on nature-related financial disclosures. Do you think the combination of these things is is effective? Um I'm particularly interested in whether going down the nature markets route is the right approach where we might start to see trading in nature credits. It's already at an experimental stage. Do you see that as being a powerful lever or is that a distraction?
SPEAKER_03Great question. Big picture, I think, that making the economic arguments is absolutely essential. Um, because without that, um, we're letting nature continue to have a price because it does have a price, and it's just zero in decisions because it doesn't feature on balance sheets or on PLs. So um, yes, we need to replace the economy within nature, and finding ways of uh doing that in different frameworks, like the TNFD you mentioned, is very helpful. Over 700 early adopters now, and alongside then the science-based targets network that also has more and more companies starting to get their targets validated, are signs that there is uptake and interest. It isn't only by itself, it's you know, it's not the sort of silver bullets, and you asked about the nature markets as well. In our whole um space or community of uh sustainability professionals, we have a tendency to be incredibly self-critical and critical of each other's, and we're always looking for the one silver bullet that's gonna solve all of these issues in one go. And we need it doesn't exist. We need to be realizing that there are many different pieces of this puzzle that we need to be pulling at the same time and that they don't compete with each other. We cannot be cannibalizing each other's efforts, it's not helping. In fact, all it's doing is creating more fragmentation within our own community that is weakening what we're trying to shift, which are these system shifts. So there is absolutely a role for nature markets. There are, of course, principles that need to be respected within that, and we need to learn from the climate space as well. But we also shouldn't be saying that that is going to solve all of the issues.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_03Um, but along with others, like incentive reform, getting the right policies in place, companies recognizing that within their strategies, you know, their business, you know, that they are investing in restoration and regeneration, there are a number of pieces that need to come together, and we can't be dividing the pie amongst ourselves. We need to be growing the pie so that we're really creating uh the momentum that's necessary.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_02Great. Um thank you, Eva, and um you make a really good point about not fracturing efforts, and I think there's something in what you're saying, which is perhaps we need businesses in particular to get better at using their existing collaborations. Um, so rather than a thousand flowers blooming, you know, how do we sort of ensure that collaborations are maybe more focused and join the system together rather than sort of fracture the system? And that leads me to my last question for you, if I may. So, business for nature does what it says on the tin. You're trying to harness the power of business to really accelerate this nature transition. If there were one or two things, and it might be, you know, the collaboration point, but it might be something different. If there's one or two things that you would love business to do more of or to do better when it comes to centering nature at the heart of our economy, our decision making, because we are nature. You spoke about that very eloquently. What is the one or two things that you would ask a business right now, at this moment in time, to ensure that we get to that transition where nature is embedded everywhere? Two things.
SPEAKER_03One is start valuing nature within your company and understand the nature-related risks of losing it. We work in an environment and an economic system where we value nature when it's dead, when timber is cut, when fish are caught, when soil is degraded, and we need to shift to valuing nature that is the living, breathing, regenerating systems, and that has a value. And if businesses start to recognize that and embed it in their mainstream decision making and disclosure, that will send a signal to others and they can learn from them. Um and by the way, we have uh there are nearly 50 companies with that have already embedded nature in their strategies, and that's available on It's Now for Nature as a global campaign. So one is within the company, and then the second is for companies to be part of advocating for the policy change that's required. And sure that has to continue to happen at a global level. Um, you mentioned the global biodiversity framework, which is a really historic and super ambitious piece of multilateral agreements, by the way, if you haven't looked at it. But it's also at the national level, it's being part of those conversations with governments that are trying to implement this that need to have government-led or government-endorsed uh business action plans. So you give the confidence, and then the question for businesses do you want to be then told what you need to be doing, or are you going to be part of shaping that agenda? And that's what we would really encourage those ahead of the curve not being passive and just reactive. But there is a all of these different frameworks are asking for information, whether it's a reporting requirement or whatever. If you get stuck into the checklist, you won't be getting the real value from that exercise. We're not, even if you close your eyes and you put your hands over your ears, it's not gonna stop nature loss. If you report or you don't report, it's not gonna, but that information will start to flow through the system and recognize and reward the right performance that goes beyond financial to include environmental and social too. Great.
SPEAKER_00Well, thanks so much, uh Eva, for joining us and and making the point really that you change a system by changing it at multiple levels and all the different facets that you can all at the same time. Thanks so much and keep up the good work.
SPEAKER_03Thank you, Eva. Thank you so much. Thanks both. Bye.
SPEAKER_02As with all of our guests, that was amazing. Um, so brilliant to hear from Eva. Who do we have next, Wayne?
SPEAKER_00Well, Sally, next we have someone who I know you uh know well the And and and love, and that is uh Shamin Love, and she's uh Chief International Advocacy Officer at Natura and Company, the world's largest B Corp, where she leads global strategy for structural and cultural change towards a regenerative economy. She's a co-founder of B Lab UK and of change agency Volans. Uh she's also executive in residence at Oxford Said Business School, where she teaches a regenerative business MBA course. She serves on the TNFD, the Task Force on Nature Related Financial Disclosures, and is a founding member of the TISFD and acts as a legal representative for Mother Nature and Future Generations on the board of House of Hackney, something I know we're both great fans of. So let's hear from O'Neill.
SPEAKER_02Welcome, Shah. Lovely to see you. Thank you so much for joining our podcast, Dancing with Systems, with a focus on the transition of our natural systems, all things nature. And what a brilliant person you are to join us in this conversation. So my first question is where are we in the repositioning of nature in business? What are the opportunities? What are the challenges?
SPEAKER_01Thank you, Sally. And I have to say, I am loving the name of this podcast. I have to, I wanted to come in almost like starting to dance a little bit. And this idea of dancing with systems is just such a great way to frame the way we have to approach systems change, but doing it with joy and with movement and with connection because you kind of dance with others. And so I think the framing of this conversation is fantastic. And as it relates to the conversation we're having today about nature, I think, you know, one of the things that I've been reflecting on a lot is the sense that actually we kind of have to re-remember as humans that we are actually all ourselves, nature. Like we're we're all part of the system. And there was a great podcast done by Outreach and Optimism last year, and it was really around this like relationship we have with nature. And that was something that really resonated with me. So I think you know, if we want to take a high altitude view of where are we with nature, I think we're in a really um like an interesting moment where I think that re-remembering for many people is starting to happen. And that's partially because we are seeing the the impacts of when we see nature under threat, and that that threat actually impacts us as humans. Um and also I think there's this craving to sort of find what are what are some ways in which we can operate in in greater harmony with nature, sensing that that's probably an important part of the path that we need to get ourselves out of the problems that we're in. I learned a new word recently, which I really like, and it's this word, um, the symbiocene, and that being, you know, where we we go from the Anthropocene to the symbiocene, which is that that time where we do find ways to live in harmony and in the rhythm of with nature. Um so I think that's both an area of opportunity, um, but it's also an area of challenge because that is a cultural change that we need to go through. Um, I think it's also you know one of the everyday um reminders that we've got, which is everything we do, everything business makes uh and sells, all of it is linked to nature, and we are we are part of that. So I think that's the the big awakening that I feel excited, I think seeing is starting to happen more and more.
SPEAKER_02And can I just ask um Shah, just to follow up to that, what has happened to reposition nature in that way? So for many of us, we've been talking about the fundamental reliance on nature as people, as businesses, and you know, nature wasn't talked about as much as it is now, and actually in the current world in which we live in, actually, nature is proving a much more durable conversation than other aspects of the sustainability agenda. So, what has happened from a sort of systems point of view? What levers have been pulled to kind of bring nature into the heart of many business conversations?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, well, when we talk about systems change, I think there are different elements, right, that become enablers. Um, there's there's structural enablers and there are um you know cultural enablers as well. And I think what we've seen are those two forces in play. Um, so from a structural perspective, I think the amazing work by done by the TNFD has been extraordinary. And I'll admit I'm a member of the TNFD, so with full disclosure, but I think really the the multi-year deep level of work to really understand how we can imagine and how do we we actually build these sorts of disclosure models, um I think is really, really critical. Like that has been a key part of that sort of structural element. And at the same time, we also have this cultural uh piece that's happening as well, where again, I think people are remembering and getting really excited when they have opportunities to be in nature, they feel themselves becoming healthier, um, more energy, and I feel like there's a more openness to be in nature, um, just based on people needing to find ways to sort of separate themselves away from some of the sort of more intense screen-based work that many people are finding themselves in. So again, I feel like there's both that cultural and that structural change that seems to be happening.
SPEAKER_00And I'm interested, uh, you mentioned the TNFD, the task force on nature-related financial disclosures. To what extent do you think we're learning from the climate movement and all of their progress, but also all of their mistakes? And I want to frame it in a larger question, which is is it the right approach to say that the reason we haven't made progress is because we haven't measured everything and we haven't quantified everything and we haven't disclosed everything? Is that really going to be the thing that triggers the transformation? Um has that really worked for climate? The other thing in the in the larger context, of course, is that we do have our own equivalent of the Paris Climate Agreement now with the uh the Kunming Montreal uh biodiversity framework. So is is that do you see that having the same kind of impact that the Paris Climate Agreement had on the nature field? So just comparing the two, I'd be interested in your reflection.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, I that's a really important question to think about what we can learn from other parts of addressing some of these systemic challenges. And I think the TNFD has very much followed many of the models of what was the TCFD. And I think what's exciting is we're also seeing the TISFD come through as well, which is the task force for inequality and social financial disclosures. And I do believe that actually we're in this moment where these different forms of disclosure making, what I get excited about is where this is going next, where we see a greater integration across these, where we recognize we, you know, there are specific elements that are really critical to each of these areas around climate, nature, inequality, and social and the people-related side of this. Um, but also how do we start seeing ways in which these different ways, these different approaches can weave together so that we see a greater level of integration. Um, to your point about, you know, yes, we've got the climate agreement and we've got the global biodiversity framework. I mean, again, I think these are really, really important instruments that give us a common set of languages and a common set of targets and destinations that we can all agree are critically important. What then we have to do is find ways to make sure we're implementing. And I think that's the piece that I'm excited about seeing the nature community really working on, which is, you know, we've taken a long time to like set the targets and move to implementation. And again, we're not moving fast enough, in my opinion, on any of this. But I think what we can do is see implementation happening on nature by learning some of the things that have um, you know, that that we've seen in the climate movement. And again, what I'm excited about next is what happens when we start applying this to issues around inequality and the social risks that are out there. Um, to your other point, though, which you made about um, you know, the quantification. I mean, one of the things that we do at Natura is we actually have an integrated profit and loss, an IPL. And we've been doing that for a really long time, right? Um We published our first EPL, environmental profit and loss, I think it was in 2014, and subsequently we've done a natural or a social uh profit and loss, and then we've integrated the four capitals together. So the social capital, the human capital, natural capital, and of course our financial capital as well. And that becomes both a means to report out, and it's a really important like heat map for us so that we can see where are there areas where the externalities and the impacts that we're creating are both positive, but also where are those that are negative. So again, that's a transparency tool for us to be really open, but we also use it internally for decision making. Um, so when we're starting to look at strategic projects, we want to make sure that we're able to value the fullness of what the impact of those projects are. So again, financial, of course, as a as a business, but we also are looking at the natural capital, the social capital, and the human capital. So again, I really feel like it's an important tool to use in decision making. Um, it's also a strategic tool for us because we have a goal to be a regenerative business by 2050. And for us to meet that goal, we will need to show that we are creating positive impact across all four of those capitals. And importantly, that they're not offsetting each other. In other words, we can't be doing really well in the social capital and not so good in the natural capital. It has to be a positive across all four of them. So that's where the idea of putting numbers to some of this work actually becomes a fundamental management tool and sort of strategic tool to guide us on the journey that we have to be regenerative. Um, so I think there is a really important role for that. But it's not to say you have sort of a quantifiable approach and then that's it. Like we also need to take this into a cultural construct. So that's why, again, the framing of systems for me is yes, having these structures and having culture around it. So again, culture we know is is what people do when nobody's looking and it's um you know so hungry. It doesn't just eat strategy for breakfast, cultural eat everything for breakfast. So I really do believe we need to have yeah, both those structures and a cultural space where the norms are such that this is the work that's being supported across the board.
SPEAKER_00Makes sense.
SPEAKER_02And um, yeah, no, it makes complete sense. And from yeah, a systems perspective, it's both structural and cultural. You're so right there. Just I guess a couple of sort of final questions for you, if we may. Um what do you think Shah would accelerate the sort of you know, the repositioning of nature and bringing nature into sort of the centrality of decision making? You know, it could be that everyone needs to have an IPL and you know, really have admired the early move of Natura on this front. So, what is that sort of lever of acceleration that needs pulling? And then for people listening to this podcast and really curious about what more they could do when it comes to nature, what's your advice for those change makers in business that can see we're fundamentally reliant on nature, um, but perhaps might not be as advanced as you are at Natura? So, what's that acceleration lever? And what is it that individual change makers could do and their own organizations?
SPEAKER_01Great, two great questions. Um, maybe I'll start with you know, what can organizations do? I mean, we've talked about the IPL, um, but in addition to my role at Natura, I also have this really interesting role at the House of Hackney, which is a UK B Corp. Um, it works in uh the interior, luxury interiors design um sector, um, where last year I was appointed to be the legal representative for Mother Nature and Future Generations on the board. And I think this comes to a big piece around governance, which I think is really important for businesses. And a governance is a word that gets used a lot, and sometimes people don't really fully think about what it means. But ultimately, if you boil it down, governance is about how decisions are made and who's making those decisions. So I feel like that's a really important part of how we think about it. Now, whether or not your organization puts nature on the board or not, I mean, I would advocate that this is a really interesting frontier of governance is representation for nature. How do we make sure nature has a voice and has a way of having a view on the decisions that are being made across the organization? But at least thinking about um the sorts of questions nature, a nature representative would have within an organization is a is a really interesting way to approach this. And I think we are gonna see this nature governance piece like rapidly rise up the conversations and the implementation of governance systems to drive nature positive action. So alongside the IPL or a nature PL or a way in which we're valuing the externalities, having decision-making frameworks that enable directors to make decisions, and not just directors, but everyone within the organization to make decisions with this idea of like what would nature, what would nature say? Um, what impacts is what we're about to have on nature and therefore kind of coming full circle on ourselves. Um and the reason why I think this is gonna speed up um the agenda is uh we had Harvard Business School come in and do a case study on this idea, should you put nature on the board? Uh, from House of Hackney. So went through the whole process of very intense interviews and discussions to create this teaching case. And earlier on this year it was taught to all 900 Harvard MBAs. Again, all of them are posed the question, you know, should you put nature on the board? So I think the fact that this is getting into business school systems, um, there was just a piece in the FT this weekend, um, you know, two pages on should you put nature on the board. I I think we're gonna see um a lot of uh innovation and momentum around this idea of nature governance. So I think that's pretty exciting.
SPEAKER_02Love it. And one of the key ways in which we can accelerate systems transition is engaging in different perspectives in the system, and actually putting nature on the board means that you have to engage with nature's perspective. So I do think that's incredibly powerful.
SPEAKER_01I think the things that individuals can do, you know, because we're talking about IPLs and we're talking about governance models, and some of those things might feel a little bit distant for some people working in organizations, but I really believe that there is this important movement, collective, awakening, reawakening that's happening. And I think for every single person, the way that we can be a part of that is just to stop and appreciate nature. Yeah, you know, I I know sometimes I have a tendency of going and taking my phone out when I see something particularly beautiful and taking a picture, and I'm actually trying to build the discipline to not do that, to actually instead of taking up my camera, just spending time looking at what beautiful inspiration made me want to capture it, and rather than capturing it, like just deeply appreciating it. So that's one of the ways I think everybody can kind of connect back in with nature is through that sense of appreciation. Um, and the other thing that I'm doing a lot of right now is reading a lot of beautiful poetry about nature, and this comes back to the cultural piece. You know, it was Nigel Topping who was the obviously high-level champion of COP26, and he said something that stuck with me so deeply. He said, you know, we must be guided by the science, and we will be moved by the poetry. And I think the science is super clear on the level of urgency, um, the proportionality of the challenges that we're facing. And I think we as humans need to find the ways to really feel this moment. And again, stopping to appreciate nature, really appreciating it, inviting others to appreciate it with you, and finding ways to sort of share the poetry. Um, those are the ways that I'm think everybody can have a role to play, and again, re-establishing that connection with nature.
SPEAKER_02Beautiful. Wonderful. Thank you so so much. Appreciate it.
SPEAKER_00Well, I just loved that. Uh such amazing insights, and also, you know, bringing, I think, the the human side. Uh what did you take away from that?
SPEAKER_02I took away um I guess two uh quite obvious insights. One is that frameworks like TNFD are great and they are useful because they allow us to understand risks and data, but on their own, they aren't enough to transition a system. We need both structural database levers as well as cultural levers. We heard a lot there about culture. And I love the idea of nature on the board, and it works because in order for systems to transition, we need to engage with different parts of the system. And when it comes to nature, if the system isn't at the table, it's much, much harder to engage with it. So I love this notion of representing nature, and we see it with uh voices from youth and other communities, is giving people a seat at the table means that we have to engage with diverse perspectives, and that's critical for any system's transition. What about you?
SPEAKER_00Well, a little bit similar to you on the frameworks, I think uh IPL, the integrated profit and loss uh that was mentioned is is a really useful tool. But I also think there's a danger there because how do you get to some of those valuations of nature? Well, often it's by valuing nature when it's dead, when it's timber, or or when it's uh you know fish that have been caught and consumed. So again, just uh wanting to to resist that a little bit, I think it's useful, but it's it's not giving us uh that a living system, which is really what we need to protect and value. I also thought some of the language shifts we were picking up are really interesting and important. So you know, maybe talking less about sustainability and talking more about risk and resilience. Or uh this new language we're starting to hear going from the Anthropocene to the symbiocene. I mean, I love that symbiosis, you know, uh really connecting and living more in harmony with nature. And I think this does come down, and uh you know, I think uh Shaman really made this point too, to the personal connection we have to nature. We must never forget about that. It reminds me of the uh the great E. O. Wilson, uh the great biologist who coined the phrase biophilia, the love of nature, and that that is actually inherent to what it means to be human. And I think uh we we need to tap into that rather than be embarrassed about that. So um well, we're at the point uh near the end where we think about uh a dance that represents nature. So, what's it for you?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, this one came to me straight away, and it is the rumba, which is often referred to as the dance of love, and we need to learn to love nature more. It is fundamental to our human health, our economic health, and uh the rumba is often danced in bare feet, so literally you have to connect to nature. So for me, it's a beautiful, hypnotic, swaying rumba.
SPEAKER_00Absolutely, you have to be grounded literally, so that's wonderful. Well, for me, um you know, for me, I would go for an for an African dance, maybe for the similar reason, right? Uh I I was born in Africa and I've I've always loved that uh that sense of a you know a s a strong beat, a rhythm, and we see that in nature, of course, full of those uh wonderful cycles and rhythms. Um but also usually a lot of stamping and and and connecting literally through our feet uh to the earth and at the same time really high energy often. And I think uh you know that that is uh nature personified. So uh well that brings us to the end of this episode, but I think it's a good time to reflect on the whole season. So um let's do that now. Um what were your reflections on uh season one of Dancing with Systems?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I mean, first of all, what an extraordinary journey through Six Systems Transitions. So many insights. Um I think listening to our guests and talking with you is just Reminded me that there are multiple levers for systems change. We like codifying things at Forum for the Future, so we've talked about eight. There are multiple levers, but they do need to be used often in a certain order. And if we pull too heavily, for example, on that policy lead lever before we've pulled the lever of cultural societal norms, then the policy won't work. And so it's just really interesting. We heard about all of the levers, and some are used more than others.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and I I was looking out for four levers that I always think are absolutely critical to systems change, and those are indeed the levers of policy, but also of markets, how we're using the incentives and sometimes the uh you know the the codes and standards that give market signals, um, but also technology and innovation, uh, and then social movements, and and again, I think we heard uh about all of those. What I find interesting and important is that uh not only is the order sometimes important, but it's it's how they influence each other. Actually, we always need all of the levers to be pulled uh and to influence each other. So uh yeah, I I I think that's true. W what about you?
SPEAKER_02Um I think I just heard something I sort of already knew, um, but it's worth reminding ourselves. We tend to get fixated with frameworks and particularly labels. So I do a lot of work in regenerative agriculture, and really quickly the conversation goes to well, what should we put on pack? Um and a label on on its own won't shift a system. Um, and so I think the conversations that we've had from food through to energy through to nature tell us that frameworks and labels are useful but not sufficient in order to drive systemic change. Um but I think running through all six episodes like a golden, beautiful thread, is actually what really, really, really matters is understanding the power of culture and that human nature of us all that underpins any transition. Um, you know, I loved Johnny's story about the work he's doing in Tottenham, where he's using culture as a vehicle to engage citizens on climate and enabling them to feel empowered to take action. Um, often for the first time, people in that community were finding the conversation around climate really unrelatable. But Johnny, through his barber, that's how it started, has sort of tapped into the underlying culture and is using art to sort of really galvanize a community. Um, and then we heard other sort of takes on cultural shifts from food to nature, even tech. We're seeing that actually people galvanizing over an issue that they care about could provide some accountability into the system. And so I have always thought this, but these episodes underpin for me in the end, the story of systems transition will be a story of people.
SPEAKER_00Yes, and and it it goes to one of those deepest levers uh of Danella Meadows when we talk about cultural or even mindset shift. It's the hardest lever to pull, but but the most fundamental because it can have the most uh impact. And when I think about cultural shifts, mindset shifts, uh, you know, it's it's sort of intangible, um, but it it it links so well to the idea of of societal myths. Now, uh I'm a uh an enthusiastic student of mythology, and people often think myths are lies. Well, no, they're not. They're they're the meta-stories, the narratives that we all live by, actually. And so one of the things I think in these system transitions that we've been exploring is can we change the story? Can we change the uh the meta-narrative? So um, yeah, uh are we are we reinforcing the current narrative? Are we seeding a new narrative? What are we tapping into? What are we uh sort of uh reinforcing?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and I think we've heard in all six episodes there is space and potential for new narratives, and actually in the end, they are going to be really critical. And in terms of building those narratives, there are sort of two critical success factors, and we heard this back in the energy episode, which is we need to be a little bit more pragmatic. Um we tend to strive for perfection sometimes where perfection might not exist, and that's a really important feature of systems change. It isn't black and white, there's so much grey, and it's never ever either or. And so that sort of need for pragmatism in building those new narratives, and critically what we also heard was the need to engage diverse and different perspectives. Um, that seems to be really important.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and and whenever we think of diverse perspectives, that leads on to another theme that I I saw coming up again and again, which is that we need collaboration. There's no single actor in a system, no matter how big they may seem to be or how powerful, that can make a system change on its own. Uh and so getting together in partnerships, maybe cross-sector, maybe it's business and and civil society, maybe it's ac academia government, all of these things are important. But uh, as we know, collaboration is really hard, which is why, you know, we don't see more of it. It's why maybe uh, you know, partnerships occurred in both the Millennium Development Goals and then was uh adopted again in the Sustainable Development Goals. It's absolutely fundamental, but it's hard to do, so we need to keep working at it. Anything else that you picked up?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and I think just there is something actually which really struck me, but just a little final point on collaboration. What we heard through the examples that are working from the big UK product project to harness the power of nature for climate adaptation through to lots of other examples is having that shared goal, having a goal where everyone can see themselves in a shared future is really important.
SPEAKER_00If I can jump in on that because we're now sort of uh sparking things for each other, but uh I think that's absolutely right. There's a formula for change, for systems change, which I always uh come back to. It's called Beckhard's formula, which says that you have to overcome the resistance to change using three factors. And and the one is there has to be uh dissatisfaction with the status quo, but then to your point there has to be a vision, and the vision is that purpose, and then in addition to your point of pragmatism, there has to be first concrete steps. So uh R resistance must be less than uh you know uh D dissatisfaction times V vision times F F for first steps.
SPEAKER_02Formula for systems change, amazing. Yeah, moving on to I think another big insight for me is um really in response to an age-old question between people in sustainability, which is can you change systems from the inside or do you have to change them from the outside? And of course it's both. Um, but I think outside or inside is a function of where the system is in transition. So at that early stage of systems transition where you're making the case for change and where people can see that dissatisfaction, that's usually an external force on the system. You know, in the case of our energy transition, it was scientists spotting what now is really very obvious shifts in our climate. So those early stages of systems transition, the forces tend to come from outside of the system. But what we heard, and this was so powerful in what Andy Cato shared, is that in order to tip a system, you often have to do it from inside because then you understand the system, you understand how to create that critical mass of acceptance, you understand the structures, the policies, the flows of finance, which if you're out of the system, would be really, really hard to understand. And so I was just really struck by that sort of outside in being linked to the sort of temporal nature of the system's transition. And of course, it's both inside and outside, but at different stages.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and since you mentioned tipping points, I also think it's worth uh giving a shout out to this concept of positive tipping points because often we're looking at breakdowns. But you know, the work of Tim Lenton uh and uh Sister Meek and and Exeter University on this is great. And Tim has a book called Positive Tipping Points, just suggesting that if we get it right, if we pull these systems levers, uh we can actually very rapidly have positive outcomes, and we need to keep that in perspective. Uh and and you know that is really a story of innovation, which just also reminds me that many of the guests we had, if you dig into their bios, didn't start out where they've ended up, right? They've had very diverse careers, but often with a kind of creative element to their careers, whether it's music or something else. And and so even that I think is a little clue to what we need in systems uh change agents, is that uh that sense of creativity.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and diversity. Yeah. Um so, yes, speaking of systems thinkers and practitioners, um, if you're listening, that includes you. Um, so we hope you've enjoyed this set of podcast episodes, Dancing with Systems, and we'd really love your help in getting the message out there. And the fundamental message we want people to take from this is our systems are undergoing rapid transition into something that could be amazing. And the more we understand those transitions and the more we understand our role in creating those transitions, then the more we can create that future that we all want.
SPEAKER_00And of course, Sally, we would love to come back for a second. Oh, we would, yeah. So uh we would uh we would love for uh Dancing with Systems to continue. So if you have suggestions for themes that we might explore, uh where we might uh dive deeper, potential guests and of course potential sponsors that will really help us. Do reach out, uh, get in touch, always uh feel open to give us feedback on what you've heard so far and what you would like to hear in the future. So I think that's just about it.
SPEAKER_02Except we need to say thank you. Um thank you to all of our guests. You know who you are. Um we really appreciate you taking time out of incredibly busy schedules. Um, thank you to Sophia River Karnak, who has been guiding us and advising us through this journey, and thank you to the amazing Lisa, who works at Forum for the Future, who has delivered a Jenga puzzle of moving parts to give you this podcast. And clearly, thank you to you all for tuning in and listening and hopefully spreading the word. Thank you, and bye.
SPEAKER_00Bye bye, see you next time.